Many trees on ancestry.com incorrectly list Frances Paynter of Boskenna as the son of William Paynter of Trelissick (1609-1669) and his wife Jane Keigwin of Mousehole (1603-1640). This is due to a combination of two factors. One is a 1930 Paynter Family Tree uploaded to some trees on ancestry.com without authorship. The other most confusing issue is a conflicting account of the Paynter family of Boskenna by John Burke Esq. in his book, A Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Landed Gentry Volume 1, first published in 1837 by Henry Colburn, London.
1930 Paynter Family Tree
Francis Paynter of Boskenna, in my opinion, is not the son of William Paynter of Trelissick and Jane Keigwin. I am sure he is a related cousin branch and at some stage more genealogy work will discover exactly how the Paynter family of Boskenna fits into the family tree.
Of great importance, Burke’s Family Records by Ashworth P. Burke, refers just the once to the Boskenna branch of the Paynter family, in his account of the Paynter family of Deverell, when Arthur Paynter of Trelissick and Mary Praed’s second son Francis Paynter of Trelissick, by his second marriage, married Margaret Paynter, the daughter of Francis Paynter of Boskenna on 8 July 1706 at St Buryan, Cornwall. Ashworth P. Burke, the grandson of John Burke Esq., treats the Boskenna Paynter branch as a separate, but probably related Paynter family. It is important to note that many of the Paynter/Painter family used their places of residence to describe their position in the family.
In an attempt to understand the very complex and impressive 1930 Paynter Family Tree, it would seem that Francis Paynter (son of William Paynter and Jane Keigwin), who married Agnes Leone, has been relegated and supplanted by Francis Paynter of Boskenna, 1639, due to a lease from Truro dated 1684, which apparently mentions Arthur Paynter of Trelissick as his brother. I have not seen this document.
This 1930 Paynter Family Tree, authored by an unknown descendant of Francis Paynter of Boskenna, placed Francis Paynter of Boskenna as a brother to Francis Paynter of St Erth, later Gwennap, claiming they were both the sons of William Paynter of Trelissick and Jane Keigwin. Frances Paynter, baptised at St Erth 14 March 1639, was given no birth details and Francis Paynter of Boskenna was given the birth date of 1639, with no place of birth given.
I have found a will document for Arthur Paynter of Penzance, dated 1682, mentioning both the Paynter families of Boskenna and of Trelissick. Here is the website link to the will of Arthur Paynter of Penzance and below I have copied the information from the website:
ARTHUR PAYNTER of Penzance, gent.
written: 26 Feb 1680
proved: 27 Oct 1682
poor of Madderne & Penzance 10 sh.
mother (not named) 20 pounds
ROBERT COUCH, gent to be release of all debts
FRANCIS NEWMAN the elder, gent. 20 sh.
DOROTHY NEWMAN w/o FRANCIS NEWMAN my 1/4 part of the garden adjoining the
Chapel of Penzance & 10 pounds
FRANCIS NEWMAN the younger (under age 15) & his sister MARY s & d/o the
said FRANCIS NEWMAN the elder & DOROTHY his wife all my lands
if the above die without issue then the lands to DOROTHY
if she died without further issue then to cousin FRANCIS PAYNTER
of Boskenna, gent., and FRANCIS PAINTER of London, gent., s/o
ARTHUR PAINTER, late of Trelissick, gent, decd.; and cousin
ELIZABETH w/o REGINALD TRENHAYLE
FRANCIS NEWMAN & MARY NEWMAN all the rest & executors
overseers: FRANCIS PAYNTER of Boskenna & DOROTHY NEWMAN
Arthur Paynter of Penzance, gent., will document, proved 27 Oct 1682
This will document of Arthur Paynter of Penzance lists a progression of inheritance if Francis Newman or his sister Mary, the son and daughter of Francis Newman and Dorothy, his wife die without issue. It then mentions Arthur Paynter of Penzance’s cousin, Francis Paynter of Boskenna and Francis Painter of London, gent., the son of Arthur Painter of Trelissick.
Arthur Painter of Trelissick (1633-1679) was the son of William Painter/Paynter of Trelissick and his wife Jane Keigwin. Note the different spellings of the surname Paynter/Painter. I have commonly found the name Paynter interchanges with Painter. The most important mention linking these Paynter/Painter families is that of Arthur Paynter of Penzance’s cousin Elizabeth, w/o (wife of) Reginald Trenhayle. She is mentioned in Burke’s Family Records as Elizabeth Paynter, the daughter of William Paynter of Trelissick and his wife Jane Keigwin. It is important to note that there is no relationship explained between Francis Paynter of Boskenna and Francis Painter of London, who later, in 1706 marries Margaret the daughter of Francis Paynter of Boskenna. Francis Painter’s father Arthur Painter, late of Trelissick, gent.
A Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Landed Gentry, (Vol 1) by John Burke
I can’t account for the confusion created by the Burke family in writing two different versions of the Paynter family of Cornwall during the 19th century, with very conflicting information. I can, however, comment on the unreliable information, brevity, lack of references and dates in John Burke’s A Genealogical and Heraldic History of the Landed Gentry. Has John Burke, the famous genealogist, in his endeavour to place the Paynter family of Boskenna into his book, muddled cousins with brothers and fallen into that dreaded genealogical trap of convenience, hypothesis and perhaps guess work?
A complete generation has been ignored in John Burke’s account of Paynter, of Boskenna with William Paynter, who married Jane Keigwin, named as the son of George Paynter and Anne Anthorne, who married 29 April 1569.
Arthur Paynter and Jane Haweis were the parents of William Paynter of Trelissick, who was baptised at St Erth in March 1609. Not only that, but George Paynter had apparently died at St Erth in 1589. Generationally, George Paynter is William Paynter’s grandfather.
What follows is equally troubling, when Arthur Paynter of Trelissick, who married Mary Praed was named as the elder brother of Francis Paynter Esq. of Boskenna, who married Margaret, the daughter of — Pawlett, Esq. of Kilborn, in Middlesex.
I have developed a family tree on ancestry.com called the Rundle Family Tree where I have placed Francis Paynter of Boskenna and Margaret Pawlett as the parents of Margaret Paynter of Boskenna, who married her cousin, Francis Paynter, the son of Arthur Paynter of Trelissick and Mary Praed. I use the word cousin, however this could easily be a second or third cousin or a removed cousin relationship.
I have not attributed Francis Paynter of Boscanna with any father; this may be resolved in time. I would enjoy and encourage correspondence with any Paynter researchers who can perhaps help me to solve the ancestry line of the Paynter family of Boskenna.
Another chapter uploaded to my website is the Paynter Family of Deverell, Cornwall. I have relied in the main on Ashworth P. Burke’s and his Burke’s Family Records for his account of the Paynter Family of Camborne. I found his listing of Cornwall Parish records incredibly reliable and accurate, especially at a time when there was no internet. He must have trawled through the Parish Books of Cornwall to achieve this feat. I have placed 5 pages from his book for the benefit Paynter/Painter researchers, as well as many of my direct descendants’ original Baptism, Marriage and Burial Records from the Parish Books of Cornwall; many still have not been transcribed. Other records for my extended Paynter family can be found on my ancestry.com Rundle Family Tree and can be copied and shared. All I ask is for is an acknowledgement of the documents you copy and reproduce.
I would like to give special acknowledgement and thanks to familysearch.org who have made the original Parish Books of Cornwall, England freely available online for those researchers who are willing to inspect the record books page by page.
3 June 2021